Question

with popular music as with classical music the only way to come to understand it thoroghly it is said is by performing .The problem with many pop bands is that their members are self tauhgt and

Answer 1

The problem with many pop bands is that their members are self tauhgt and often lack formal training in music theory and performance. This can make it more difficult for them to fully understand and appreciate the intricacies of the music they are creating and performing. However, many popular musicians are able to develop a deep understanding and appreciation of music through years of experience, experimentation, and collaboration with other musicians. Additionally, some popular bands have members with formal training in music, which can help them to better understand and perform their music.

Answer 2

lack formal training in music theory and performance. While it is true that performing music can deepen one's understanding and appreciation of it, it is not the only way to gain a thorough understanding.

In the case of classical music, performers often spend years studying music theory, history, and technique, as well as receiving formal training on their chosen instrument. This comprehensive education allows them to develop a deep understanding of the music they perform.

On the other hand, many popular music bands and artists are self-taught and may not have gone through the same rigorous training. However, this doesn't mean that they cannot have a profound understanding of their craft. Self-taught musicians often rely on their creativity, experimentation, and personal exploration of music to develop their unique style and sound.

While formal training can provide a solid foundation and a structured approach to learning music, it doesn't guarantee a deeper understanding or creativity. Many self-taught musicians have achieved great success and have contributed significantly to the world of popular music.

Understanding and appreciating any genre of music, be it classical or popular, can come from various sources. These may include listening attentively to different compositions, studying the history and context of the music, analyzing its structure and harmony, and exploring the emotions and messages conveyed through the lyrics and melodies.

Ultimately, the key to understanding and appreciating any form of music lies in active engagement and a genuine passion for the art form. Whether one is self-taught or formally trained, the desire to learn, explore, and express oneself through music is what truly matters.